Ellsberg and Afghanistan
Forgive me for interrupting the celebration over the al-Maliki «endorsement», or «mental lapse saved by CENTCOM».
Tom Hayden's conclusion, that «...ending one war Iraq to start two more in Afghanistan and Pakistan seems to be a dumb idea» in «Obama, Iraq and Afghanistan» has stuck in my head for days now. But, here's the part that really resonated.
Transferring 10,000 American troops from Iraq to Afghanistan, which Obama proposes, is symbolic, a potential down payment on the treadmill of further escalation. (In his statement, Obama supports «at least» two additional brigades for Afghanistan.) The future of the Pentagon's «rear» in Iraq will be questionable if fifteen combat brigades are withdrawn under Obama's plan, while the Pentagon's new «front» line cannot be secured with two brigades sent to southern and eastern Afghanistan. At best these might be holding actions until the next administration makes a decision about its ultimate strategy. Obama may be proposing an escalation simply in order not to lose, a pattern well-documented in Daniel Ellsberg's history of the Vietnam War.
That's because I read Daniel Ellsberg's Secrets: A Memoir of Vietnam and the Pentagon Papers years ago. Ellsberg asks additionally, if «we had a right to win».
That unspoken premise underlay one, also unspoken, held by a large and growing number of officials, former officials, and liberal members of the establishment who no longer believed in the practical feasibility of «winning» at acceptable cost. This was the assumption that we had nevertheless a a right to prolong an unwinnable war to postpone defeat or, at the very worst, to lose only gracefully, covertly, slowly, at the cost of an uncounted number of Asian lives, a roll on which they and our policy set no real limit. (p.247)
Yet, the Afghanistan campaign was the righteous mission, right? Or, was it the war to compensate for the mistakes made in the 1980s?
Sphere: Related Content
Barrapunto
CoRank Español
Delicious
Enchílame
Fresqui Ocio
Furl
Google Bookmarks
Menéame
Netscape
Newsvine
Stumbleupon
Technorati Favorites
Yahoo MyWeb
Write a comment
No trackbacks
RSS 2.0
Bloglines
Live
MyAOL
Netvibes
Newsgator
Rojo
Write a comment
If you want to add your comment on this post, simply fill out the next form:
You can use these XHTML tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>.
No comments
Be the first to write a comment on this post.
No trackbacks
To notify a mention on this post in your blog, enable automated notification (Options > Discussion in WordPress) or specify this trackback url: http://www.radicalcontrapositions.com/left_flank/2008/07/21/ellsberg-and-afghanistan/trackback/